Add to cart Papi’s Old Fashioned Mixer – ORIGINAL $12.99 375 mL bottle (makes approximately 20 cocktails) The Old Fashioned is one of the first cocktails ever created and no one makes a better Old Fashioned than Papi. His light, refreshing cocktail is complex yet delicate and lingering. For years folks from far and wide have asked Papi to provide his secret mix. Today it’s yours. Enjoy Papi’s proprietary blend of hand-made, turbinado sugar syrup, Amarena cherry juice and a dash of Baldies Bitters™ in this perfectly balanced Old Fashioned mix.